Infidelity in plain sight. A priest's girlfriend.

The situation surrounding Toni Faber in the Archdiocese of Vienna is escalating. After weeks of negotiations between the cathedral priest and Archbishop Josef Grünwidl, there are increasing indications that the talks are nearing completion, as reported by the newspaper "Die Presse."

Faber's possible departure has not yet been officially confirmed. Diocesan spokesman Michael Prüller continues to emphasize the need for restraint when speaking to the media. "The archbishop has repeatedly confirmed that the cathedral priest and the archbishop are in talks. However, as long as there is no agreement, we cannot comment further." Behind the scenes, however, it appears that a deal has now been reached regarding his departure.

Toni Faber's Departure: Church remains Discreet

Archbishop Josef Grünwidl only recently took over as head of the Archdiocese of Vienna from Cardinal Christoph Schönborn and is likely to implement his own personnel decisions. That Archbishop Faber's understanding of his role doesn't entirely align with the new archbishop's vision is an open secret. Faber's approach to celibacy, his regular appearances with Natalie Nemec, and criticism of his public persona have recently sparked public debate. This puts Grünwidl in a position to work with one of the most visible and, at the same time, most controversial proponents of a more liberal course within the Austrian Church.

Natalie Nemec and celibacy: The heart of the debate

A central point of contention in the discussions is Faber's public persona. For years, the Vienna Cathedral priest has appeared at public events, from the Opera Ball to society functions, alongside Natalie Nemec.

Faber speaks openly of a "very specific person" at his side, but deliberately avoids the term "life partner." "I don't refer to any woman as a life partner," he clarifies. At the same time, he emphasizes: “I am very happy to have Natalie by my side at official events, and as a good friend, she always knows that I stand up for her and she for me.”

Toni Faber and celibacy

The visible closeness contradicts the traditional understanding of celibacy, which not only entails renouncing marriage but also maintaining a clear emotional and public distance. Toni Faber has repeatedly advocated for a contemporary approach to mandatory celibacy and argued for greater recognition of the lived realities of many priests.

Liberal course at St. Stephen's Cathedral

Faber's approach is generally considered practical. The “city priest” advocates for an inclusive approach and emphasizes that there should be no “second-class Christians” in the Church—not even on issues such as homosexuality or modern family structures. With his liberal stance, Faber embodies a more modern, contemporary approach to the priesthood for many.

Faber's liberal course does not meet with approval in all parts of the Church. The balancing act between tradition and social reality makes him relatable and approachable for many believers, but at the same time brings him into conflict with official Church doctrine.

Cathedral priest Toni Faber in St. Stephen's Cathedral, the Vienna city priest polarizes with his views on celibacy, faith, and homosexuality.

The combination of public presence, personal guidance, and reform-oriented statements is likely a key reason for the current talks with Grünwidl. Observers interpret the talks with Toni Faber as part of a strategic realignment.

This is not just about a personnel decision, but also about how the Church in Vienna wants to position itself in the future – between tradition, reform, and public perception. Grünwidl is likely to place greater emphasis on a unified approach and a clearer adherence to church doctrine, particularly on sensitive issues such as celibacy and the public role of priests.

30 Years at St. Stephen's Cathedral: A Farewell with Symbolic Power

A potential departure of Toni Faber would coincide with a symbolically significant year. In 2027, the 64-year-old will celebrate his 30th anniversary of service at St. Stephen's Cathedral and simultaneously reach retirement age. Within church circles, this timeframe is considered ideal for an orderly withdrawal. A "face-saving solution" is being discussed, one that acknowledges Faber's long-standing service while simultaneously allowing for a fresh start under Grünwidl.

Official confirmation is still pending (now confirmed by the Archbishop!), but many signs indicate that Toni Faber's departure is drawing near. Discussions with Grünwidl are apparently nearing completion – and with them, a decision on the future of arguably Austria's most famous priest. For the Catholic Church in Vienna, Faber's departure could not only mark the end of an era but also the future of the parish.

Source