Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Who would trust the Bishops' Conferences to solve the sexual abuse crisis?

Certainly not Cardinal Baggio who in 1977 when Prefect of the Congregation of Bishops addressed the Circulo di Roma, a group of diplomats and intellectuals based in Rome.

While dressing up his assessment of Bishops' Conferences in a generally positive light, he declared that, « as they were entirely human institutions, they reveal  grandeurs and servility, ambiguity and contradictions, such as improvisation and inexperience, empiricism, group mentality when it comes to expressing an opinion, bureaucratic and administrative inertia, a refusal to take responsibility, a loss of energy and time- these defective elements lead one to consider sometimes that the Bishops’ Conferences are a aberration of pluralism »

And the then Cardinal Ratzinger writing in 1982, "it is however a fact that we have become the witnesses of a dissolution of personal responsibility of the bishop in the anonymity of collective decisions, a disolution which is without precedent in history".

Ironic indeed that conservatives and traditionalists, given their, at least, incipient ultramontanism  have a rather flatter view of ecclesiastical hierarchy than progressives and modernists.  Cardinal Manning reportedly expected a direct instruction from the Pope to be brought to him at breakfast each morning.  But there again, one would expect progressives and other socialists to rather like building bureaucracies.   It does employ them so.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Student protest against Cardinal Meisner - Radio Erft

Student protest against Cardinal Meisner - Radio Erft

Students of the teacher David Berger from Erftstadt want to demonstrate on Tuesday afternoon against homophobia and fundamentalism.

The students have organized a protest march that starts at the main station and then goes to the official residence of Cardinal Meisner. The background is the decision of the cardinal to revoke the teaching license of the avowedly gay David Berger.

Berger himself welcomed the action in a interview with Radio Erft - but stressed that he would not personally be there. It should not look as if he called on the students to take action - it was all organized by the youth alone.

Cardinal Meisner had justified the withdrawal of permission to teach with the fact that Berger does not agree with the moral and legal norms of the Catholic Church. Students criticize this attitude because it is fundamentalist in their view, and hinders free development.

Bishops' Conferences - state of play regarding guidelines

ZENIT - Aide: Many Bishops Already Have Abuse Guidelines

Interesting comment from Father Lombardi at the end praising the German Bishops' Conference for paying for victims' therapy.