Totally unjust

..not to review the parish closings that have already taken place.

"If this doesn't include a review of those parishes that have already been closed then the process has no value whatsoever,"

The panel should not even start its work until the remit is extended, as it will only be greeted with suspicion. In these circumstances, helping the work of the panel only facilitates more Church closures. Extend the remit and then the talking can begin!