SSPX to discipline Bishop Williamson

from the Mittelbayerische Zeitung

Holocaust denier Williamson threatened with consequences
Bishop Fellay is to announce possible sanctions against Richard Williamson in the coming days. "Yes. I'm already working on this," he said on Sunday outside of the chapel where Mass was being said in Zaitzkofen (Regensburg area), where the Society of St Pius maintains a seminar for priests. There the Lefebvre Bishop Richard Williamson apparently also gave the controversial television interview in which he denied the Holocaust of six million Jews. The Regensburg prosecutor is investigating whether a case of race hatred can be brought.

Fellay on Sunday gave no concrete indications of the implications of the Holocaust denial will have for Williamson in the Society of St Pius. Fellay would not confirm a possible resignation or an official withdrawal. "This is perhaps too much to say, but I do not see how Bishop Williamson now can exercise his office of bishop in many countries." Apparently, however, in any case, a strong reduction of the work of Williamson is being considered.

Lefebvre Bishop Fellay was disappointed that Williamson last Friday, in the midst of worldwide uproar, had regrets over his interview, but had withdrawn nothing substantive. "You see the situation in which we are. From this you can see that we are disappointed, " he said. Before the interview, he had known nothing of the anti-Semitic attitude of the British bishop. "As he did now, he has never spoken." He had been aware that Williamson was given to "extravagant thought" on various topics. "I had, so to speak, to attribute that “to the fact that he is British."

Anti-Semitism was always in the Society an isolated case. "In each group there are always people on the fringes." Wounds had been newly torn open with Williamson’s statement. "I apologise to those who have been hurt by this and especially the Jewish people."

Comments

Don McGovern said…
See www.plain-talking.com for some interesting comments on the Bishop Williamson outrage. What a tragedy that this baffoon has so spoilt such a wonderful moment for tradition.
Michael Reardon said…
McGovern, it is you and your kind who the bufoons. What have you ever done for the traditional Faith other than perhaps attend Mass on Sunday? As a thirty year activist within the traditional Catholic movement, the principal lay founder of two traditional parishes, one independent and one diocesan, as the lay founder of the first traditional parish in the world in Union with Rome, I have met Bishop Williamson on a number of occasions and heard him speak many times. He is a man of the highest intelligence, courage, and above all, holiness. You and your fellow wimps can continue to kick a man when he is down. Bishop Fellay and Fr. Schmidtberger are no better than you, however, for thier cowardly caving into the enemies of the Faith.
Aged parent said…
For pete's sake, let's drop all this "outrage" and move on to something else. Williamson questions the precise number of Jews murdered by the Nazis, and the precise method used by them to do the killing, and the world is in an uproar. This is simply ridiculous. Frankly, I'm sick of hearing about this and sicker still that everyone has to do cartwheels in order to appease Jewish sensibilities. After all these people have their own past heinous sins committed against Christians to worry about; they are not an "immaculately conceived" people.

Yes, Bishop Williamson should avoid political discussions and confine himself to speaking about matters of the Faith, including the matter of bringing non-believers (Jews, Muslims, etc.) into the true Church. And, yes, he has been imprudent. But enough is enough already. And if there are plans afoot to make the man grovel before "world opinion" then that would be worse than any remarks he may have made.

Let's please now start to forgive...and forget.
bead said…
I'm sick of Williamson. If anything should be dropped it should be he, not only from the possibility of ever re-entering the Church, but onto his own head.

You make it sound like his questioning the numbers of those killed in the holocaust is a trifling matter. No, he didn't say he thought only 5.98m were killed rather than 6m, he said 300-400 thousand! So what of the poor souls of those 5.6 MILLION and their families who died? Oh well, we can forget about them. MILLIONS of lives brought to a shuddering halt in the most evil barbaric manner. No big deal! Minimize their deaths! It happened a long time ago anyway and a thoroughly discredited "historian" questioned the numbers so we ought to go with what he said. Similarly with the method used to kill them. Lets just forget that these starved already-half-dead men women and children were clawing up clumps of concrete in desperation as they died together. We're just talking about innocent people here, mass genocide, heinous crimes against humanity. No big deal!

"Cartwheeling" to the Jews indeed. You make it sound like theirs and the rest of the civilized world's outrage is somehow bad and surprising! If people are rushing to side with the Jews they deserve it. If Williamson had said of the people of Rwanada, "Oh dear interviewer, are you so ignorant? Only a few hundred innocents really died in Rwanda in 1994 and none of the victims were hacked limb from limb in front of their own family members but died much more "humanely" don't you know," there would be just the same outrage and "cartwheeling", as you call it, to Rwanadans. And rightly so. You see, normal people have an ounce of compassion about them. To them, minimizing or denying almost unimaginable atrocities committed by man against man, especially on this monumental scale, strikes at the heart and they rush to stand firm with the victims. The only people this sort of thing DOESN'T affect are typically psychopaths or those who sympathise with the views and sentiments of the exterminators. Which one are you?
Anonymous said…
Unity people Unity.

We are ants compared to the Almighty God.

He is in charge and we should just shut our pieholes and pray for our Holy Father that he is given the strength to fight the wolves at the gate.

God is in charge.
Let all of us who love the Church be unified.

God bless you
Borg said…
Here is a link to the SSPX press release on B. Williamson's interview http://www.sspx.org/superior_generals_ltrs/bishop_fellay_statement_re_bishop_williamson.pdf

B. Williamson himself apologized for the imprudence of his words http://dinoscopus.blogspot.com/2009/01/letter.html

B. Williamson is not the SSPX just as the SSPX is not the Church. To blast the whole SSPX for his remarks is ignorant and absurd. And lastly, even if the SSPX is still suspended, B. Williamson is still a bishop of the Catholic Church and should be shown the respect due to his office.
Tom Massett said…
I've know His excellency Bishop Williamson for more than 25 years and he has always been an excellent Priest and Bishop. Why is it that he cannot express his personal views on an historical event? My son-in law, Tony M. made the point that any person in the world can deny the existence of God or blaspheme the Holy name of Jesus Christ and the world says nothing. But call into question the number of Jews killed during the Holocaust and the whole world condemns you. Catholics should know better than to follow the world in its condemnations.
Unknown said…
It is obvious that many of those commenting on this blog either have not read any of Bishop Williamson's writings about Jews or are clearly antisemitic. In previous letters he has accused Jews of seeking worldwide domination and preparing a throne for the anti-christ in Jerusalem. He also took "ex-Christian" countries to task for allowing the enemies of Christ (the Jews) to have freedom within their countries. Sadly I suspect that many readers of this blog agree with these sentiments based on previous postings. If you do not agree with these views then don't be fooled into believing that Bishop Williamson is being unfairly hounded as any decent person professing to follow the teachings of Jesus would be offended by this hatred.
Dolorosa said…
The Crucifixion of Bishop Williamson

http://truthisbeauty.wordpress.com/2009/01/29/the-crucifixion-of-bishop-williamson/
Dolorosa said…
So many people, including catholics, are being deceived into thinking that Bishop Williamson should just be quiet but how many saints in the past spoke out about the evils in their day. How many don't speak out against anti-catholicism but rush to defend the enemies of Christ who really hate his true church?
Kerry Ramirez said…
While I don’t always agree with everything Bishop Williamson says, I do admire his courage for expressing his opinions even if they are not politically correct. And he is a courageous defender of tradition, the same tradition that Catholics everywhere believed, that is until Vatican II. Who are the Jews to tell the Pope who he can and cannot excommunicate? The Pope isn’t telling the Jews how to run their synagogues. Since when is questioning what happened to the Jews in WWII a matter of faith? I guess we now have a new 11th Commandment: Thou shalt not question the holocaust. What happened to the Jews was horrible, but there were also many Catholics, Protestants and others who were killed. And what about the millions of aborted babies? The Jews do not have clean hands, either.
Unknown said…
herb - Christ said: "leave them alone, they (the Jews) are blind"; He also referred to them (the Jews) as "sons of Satan"; the Auschwitz (sic) museum in California has reduced the number of Jews murdered from 6.0 million to less than 2.0 million; does bringing down the Sacred Blood of the God-Man on your children mean anything to you? they murdered Jesus the Christ - should we forget that? pray for them, yes; forgive them, that is up to God since their sin is against Him, not us; Bishop Williamson should leave the SSPX, I am sure there are a large number of members of the SSPX that would leave with him; already a group is starting a Rosary Crusade to oust Bishop Fellay; what do you make of that?