It has not pleased God to save Germany by disputation

to paraphrase St Ambrose.

Prohibition on thinking

Suddenly everyone knows it: Yesterday, Robert Zollitsch officially became Chairman of the German Bishops' Conference. And the hitherto largely unknown prelate is suddenly on everyone's lips. His fellow bishops elected the Archbishop of Freiburg in the previous week to succeed Cardinal Lehmann. From then on, all wanted to know who this man is, what he believes and what he thinks. Almost overnight, a rather quiet dignitary was catapulted into the spotlight. And Zollitsch willingly talked.

The first days after his election were marked by an interview offensive. Now we know more. That he was in love and would have been happy to become a father, the Archbishop told all and spoke about his passion for mountain climbing and cactus breeding. That certainly would never kickstart the debate, which now overshadows the office of Robert Zollitsch. That was ensured his comments on a possible easing of celibacy. The connection between the priesthood and celibacy was "theologically not necessary," he said in interviews, and spoke out against “prohibitions on thinking. " One might to excuse Zollitsch say that he lacks experience in the media. He then gave a more considered opinion, and rowed back cautiously, as the discussion has produced high waves.

But considered opinions are one thing, issues another. Now, the debate is running and Catholics are stuck back into old emotional disputes. Already, the disagreement between Rome and Germany is recalled and the Church once again spins around itself. This is not only sad, but tragic. Yesterday, it was still a question of God. Today, everything is about celibacy. Let no one say, that there was not the prospect to speak about fundamental matters.

Source