15 theologians re-excommunicate Bishop Williamson

Tübinger Theologen klagen an- Tubingen theologians accuse.

Fifteen theology professors from Tubingen have criticized the lifting of the excommunication of the bishops of the Piusbruderschaft by Pope Benedict XVI. The action constitutes "a nuisance and a heavy burden" on not only their work, but also the work of many priests, pastoral staff, teachers and religious teachers, the Catholic theologians write in a joint statement. They fear that lifting the excommunication of the bishops has highlighted a turning point in post-Conciliar ecclesiastical history . Whoever strives on the basis of the Second Vatican Council for a church and a theology "in an open dialogue with the world and the religions, especially Judaism, are" feels that they have received a punch to the head. We respect the efforts of the Pope for the unity of the Church. Nevertheless, there is now in the Catholic Church bishops who reject "freedom of religion and conscience”, show an openness to an anti-ecumenical understanding, representing a clerical image of the Church within which the common priesthood of all believers has little meaning, and who "deliberately underestimate" the “Conciliar Church”. One of these bishops also denies the full extent of the Shoah and displays an anti-Semitic thinking. He stands thereby, as before, outside the communion of the church. The statement is signed by Urs Baumann, Albert Biesinger, Franz-Josef Bormann, Thomas Freyer, Ottmar Fuchs, Norbert Greinacher, Bernd Jochen Hilberath, Andreas Holzem, Joachim Kohler, Karl-Josef Kuschel, Dietmar Mieth, Andreas Odenthal, Richard Puza, Hans Reinhard Seeliger and Michael Theobald.

Comments

Peter said…
Never heard of any of them. Yawn.
pclaudel said…
Mr. Gillibrand has already taken wry note of several polls with extraordinarily tendentious questions--stuff like "Do you think Bishop Williamson is still beating his wife?" Perhaps he would be kind enough to append a poll to the present article. The yes or no question I would suggest is the following: "Would you be willing to stake five dollars [or its equivalent in quid, euros, or some other fiat currency] on a wager that a clear majority of these theologians attended Mass last Sunday?"

The follow-up question (not yes-no) is obvious: "OK, with the five bucks you just saved, who do you like in the Super Bowl?"